Baileys Cheesecake has a delicious chocolate cookie crust topped with Irish cream-spiked cheesecake filling and ganache layers.
Back in my college days, I managed a small Mediterranean restaurant near campus. It was both a place for the local neighborhood to grab a quick bite to eat and for college kids to hang out and pretend to study while sipping cappuccinos.
And since I worked a lot, and free food was a perk of the job, I pretty much lived on hummus and pita bread for over 4 years.
There was a super friendly older couple that were weekly regulars. Every week, they’d split a tawook dinner with extra steamed veggies. The husband would finish his meal with a piece of cheesecake, and the wife would order Baileys and coffee with just a smidgen of whipped cream and chocolate sauce (similar to an Irish coffee cocktail).
It’s funny the things I remember from more than 15 years ago. The names of any of my undergrad professors? Not a chance. But a meal a couple ordered every week? Yep, right down to the extra veggies.
Now, I’ve never been much of a drinker, but I developed quite an affinity for Baileys and coffee with just a smidgen of whipped cream and chocolate sauce. It’s just one of those drinks that reminds me of being in my 20s, and makes me all warm and fuzzy for so many reasons.
A few weeks ago, I picked up a bottle of Baileys Irish Cream to make Simple Homemade Truffles…and perhaps whip up a Baileys and coffee or two. And then on a whim one night, I decided to try making a Baileys Cheesecake.
WHAT IS BAILEYS CHEESECAKE?
Baileys Cheesecake really isn’t that different from my vanilla cheesecake recipe.
But instead of a graham cracker crust, I use an Oreo cookie crust for a nice chocolatey base. I also swapped out the cream in the filling for Baileys Irish Cream and topped the whole thing with a Baileys-spiked chocolate ganache.
The result is a creamy cheesecake with just the right amount of chocolate and Baileys flavor.
I’d like to think this would have been the perfect cheesecake to finally tempt the wife of that sweet couple into joining her husband in a slice of cheesecake. But then, I happen to think life is not worth living without cheesecake. Are you with me?
TIPS FOR MAKING THIS IRISH CREAM CHEESECAKE
There are three main parts to this Baileys Irish cream cheesecake:
- Oreo cookie crust
- Baileys-infused cheesecake filling
- Baileys-spiked chocolate ganache topping
I have made many, many cheesecake recipes through the years, so I have a few tips I’ve learned along the way that can help you as you make this recipe:
- Use room-temperature cream cheese and eggs. If you forget to set these ingredients out ahead of time, you’re in luck. I have tutorials for how to soften cream cheese and how to bring butter and eggs to room temperature.
- Bake the cheesecake in a water bath. Don’t be intimidated by this step – it’s easier than you think and will help make sure your cheesecake is absolutely perfect. Check out my post on how to bake cheesecake in a water bath.
- Give yourself plenty of time. Even though getting the cheesecake in the oven doesn’t take a ton of time, it needs about an hour to bake, a couple of hours to cool, and 8 hours to chill in the refrigerator. Don’t be tempted to take shortcuts here.
Could you use a store-bought crust instead of making your own? Yes.
Could you skip the chocolate ganache on top? Sure.
Would the final cheesecake be as good? Well, I know what my opinion is, but I’ll let you decide that on your own.
CAN BAILEYS CHEESECAKE BE FROZEN?
This Baileys Cheesecake is the perfect candidate for freezing! Since cheesecake is a bit time intensive to make, it is sometimes nice to make it ahead of time and freeze it.
I recommend freezing this cheesecake without the ganache on top and adding the ganache before serving.
Once the cheesecake has chilled thoroughly in the refrigerator, place it on a cardboard round and wrap it in plastic wrap, then in foil. If you have a large zip-top freezer bag, you could even store it inside that for an extra layer of protection.
The idea is to have at least 2 layers of protection around the cheesecake to keep it from getting freezer burn.
Let the Baileys Cheesecake thaw in the refrigerator overnight or at room temperature for a couple of hours before topping with the ganache and serving.
Let’s all make this Baileys Irish Cream Cheesecake and toast sweet couples who are married for decades, with the sweetest of weekly traditions. What a way to live, right?
Wednesday 15th of March 2023
Getting ready to bake this tomorrow. I noted the freezing reccomebdation to place it on a cake round. I struggle to remove cheesecake from the bottom of springform. I often use a parchment round but then can't get that off without damaging cake and if I leave it, sometimes it gets messy when serving. Would love any tried and true suggestion for getting cake safely from springform to cardboard round. Thanks!
Thursday 16th of March 2023
Hi Cheryl – If you won't need your springform pan for a bit, you could leave it on the bottom of the springform and freeze it on that instead! The only reason I usually recommend trying to transfer it is in case folks need their springform pan for something else in the meantime. My other suggestion is to put a piece of parchment that's larger than the bottom of the springform pan at the bottom and secure the springform ring over it (wrap the edges of the parchment around the bottom of the pan + then attach the ring). Then when you take off the ring, you can use the edges of the parchment to scoot the chilled cheesecake onto the cardboard. Hope this helps! Jamie
Wednesday 8th of March 2023
If I were to halve this recipe and use a 6” springform pan, what would you estimate the bake time to be?
Wednesday 15th of March 2023
Hi there – I haven't made this change on this recipe, so I can't speak to the necessary baking time. If you give it a try, I'd love to know how it turns out. Happy baking! Jamie
Sunday 26th of February 2023
I don’t know if this has already been asked or not, but if I’m making the crust from scratch, so I crush up the Oreos with the icing? Or do I scrape the filling out and just use the cookie part?
Thursday 2nd of March 2023
Hi Katie – You use the whole Oreos, with the filling inside. Happy baking! Jamie
Sunday 29th of January 2023
@Steve, I followed your recs and it came out perfect, at least I think it did. I made it for a dessert auction and with a small bottle of Baileys on the side, it was one of the most popular items. Went for $70
Wednesday 30th of March 2022
Hello, If I were to make this in cupcake shape so smaller cheesecakes, how would the recipe change? Would love to know! Thank you in advance
Wednesday 30th of March 2022
Hi there! I have not tried making this particular recipe into mini cheesecakes, but you can check out this recipe and use a similar method: https://www.mybakingaddiction.com/mini-cherry-almond-cheesecakes/. If you give it a try, I'd love to know how they turned out. Happy baking! -Jamie