These Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies surround a creamy peanut butter filling with two peanut butter oatmeal cookies. Forget crumbly peanut butter cookies – you’ll love the chewy texture and peanut butter punch of these sweet sandwich cookies!
I don’t know what it is about spring, but our schedule seems insane right now. Well, let me rephrase that, Elle’s schedule is insane.
Between ballet recital rehearsals, piano, karate, and her neighborhood social life, this kid has a fuller Google calendar than my personal and work calendars combined.
The busyness has forced me to stay on top of my meal planning game and dinners like Chicken Piccata, Ritz Cracker Chicken, and Easy Crockpot Pulled Pork are in heavy rotation around here.
If I’m being honest, we’re kind of in a chicken rut, so I picked up a new-to-me cookbook to find some quick and easy dinner inspiration. And let me tell you, the chicken lettuce wraps are our new favorite meal around here! Yes, another chicken recipe, but it is so good!
I’ve also not been super inspired in the cookie department because we’ve been so obsessed with these Chocolate Chip Cookies, so I decided to start whipping up some more of my old favorites, starting with these Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies.
THE BEST PEANUT BUTTER COOKIES
I have done quite a bit of research on peanut butter cookies. Not the Peanut Butter Blossom kind, although those are some of my favorite cookies – the kind with the criss-cross pattern on top.
I have read blogs, recipe websites, message boards, cookbooks, and anything else I could get my hands on.
Most of the peanut butter cookie recipes I have tried had great reviews, but in my opinion made a less than desirable cookie.
Some of them lacked peanut butter flavor and most an odd crumbly texture. I am as anti-crumbly-cookie as they come!
At that point I decided to try a recipe from AllRecipes. Some reviews for this recipe stated that these cookies actually tasted like my favorite Girl Scout cookies, so of course I was curious.
I made the first batch according to the instructions. I plopped the cookies down by the teaspoon full and baked for 10 minutes. Well, I ended up with slightly crunchy cookies in irregular shapes.
If you didn’t know it before, I’m a bit of a perfectionist. Therefore, along with hating crumbly cookies, I also dislike irregular-shaped cookies and I decided to adjust a couple of components.
I ended up baking for them about 7 minutes and rolled the cookies into balls before pressing them down with the fork. I ended up with soft, chewy, perfectly shaped cookies.
In my opinion, this recipe makes my hands-down favorite peanut butter cookie – it’s delicious!!
(Psst! Want to make the dough ahead and freeze it for later? Follow my method for how to freeze cookie dough!)
MAKING PEANUT BUTTER FILLING
But you can’t make peanut butter cookies that taste just like the Girl Scout stand-bys without turning them into sandwich cookies.
That would be like making Homemade Samoas without coconut or Homemade Thin Mints without chocolate!
The best thing about Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies is how the creamy peanut butter filling balances out the texture of the cookies and adds an extra layer of peanut butter flavor.
These cookie sandwiches are a peanut butter lover’s dream.
Making the peanut butter filling is pretty similar to making Homemade Buttercream Frosting or the frosting for Apple Peanut Butter Cupcakes. You can choose to spread it or pipe it on to make the Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies. Either method works great!
HOW DO YOU STORE PEANUT BUTTER SANDWICH COOKIES?
You can store Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies in an airtight container at room temperature for up to three days.
You may also store them in the refrigerator if your house is particularly warm. I recommend letting them come to room temperature before serving.
Tuesday 23rd of February 2021
This recipe leaves you with as close as youre going to get to the old Burry Gaucho cookies which are also the same as Gurl Scouts Do Si Dos. Fantastic!
Thursday 25th of February 2021
Yes! they are so close to Do-Si-Dos! I need to make these again very soon! -Jamie
Sunday 6th of December 2020
These look fabulous! Is it possible to make them gluten free?
Thursday 10th of October 2019
I made these for the Facilities and Purchasing department at my Community College in California. The person i replaced in my office made sweets for the Security staff for years, and since my favorite in that office moved to Facilities, I realized i had three batches to make. I took over for Sue. Whose cookies have i made the last 2 weeks? Yours!! They loved these Peanut Butter Sandwich cookies. OMG. My Mom is turning in the heavens as I made them big and not bite sized. Sorry Mom! The flavor of the cookie and the filling were delicious. Yesterday I got told that they are very filling and very good!! Today, the empty container came back and they said they were the best ever! I am going to make them again this next week. I have not made oatmeal cookies in decades. I am proud to make your recipe!
Thursday 10th of October 2019
So happy to hear you enjoyed the cookies, Kathy! Thanks so much for stopping by and leaving your feedback! -Jamie
Monday 29th of July 2019
can I freeze them?
Saturday 3rd of August 2019
Hello! I haven't attempted freezing these, so I am not sure of the result. If you happen to give it a try, I'd love to know how they turned out. Thanks so much for stopping by. -Jamie
Friday 5th of July 2019
These sound amazing! What if I don't have heavy cream? What can I use in its place?
Wednesday 10th of July 2019
Hello! You could use milk if you don't have heavy cream. You may not need as much milk as cream to thin out the filling, so add it a little bit at a time until the consistency is right. Hope this helps! Happy baking. Jamie